Warning: This article contains spoilers about episode 2 of The Challenge: All Stars, streaming now on Paramount+.

Trishelle Cannatella is no stranger to stirring up drama on reality TV. The 41-year-old got her start on The Real World: Las Vegas in 2002 and helped steer the long-running reality franchise into new waters as the cast partied harder, drank, and hooked up on camera more than all the previous seasons combined. After her Real World season ended, Cannatella went on to star on many other reality shows such as Punk'd, The Surreal Life, Battle of the Network Reality Stars, and more, not to mention her multiple stints on The Challenge. So even though her return for The Challenge: All Starsboasted an older, wiser, and more mature version of who people saw on TV decades ago, it's no surprise that Cannatella found herself in yet another verbal altercation, only two episodes in.