Despite the glaring lens of the public eye, some celebrities have managed to keep their relationships totally private until after the breakup!

When you’re a celebrity, it’s safe to say that at least some of your life, whether you like to or not, is public information. Whether it’s the brands you love, where you live, or who you’re dating, the public can’t help but be nosy about what their favorite celebrities are up to. And, knowing how hard it is for celebrities to keep anything private, from secret baby bumps to secret weddings, we totally applaud those who’ve managed to keep things under wraps — especially when it comes to their relationship.