Be it a guilty pleasure or not, true crime documentaries have often taken discourse every once in a while for just how wild and unbelievable these stories can get.

Take Netflix’s The Staircase, for instance. The docuseries, which follows the mysterious case of Michael Peterson following the death of his wife, Laci, captivated audiences. After all, with a husband determined to speak his truth, and an “owl theory” that leaves viewers in shock, the case is one of the most riveting ones in history.

Luckily, The Staircase isn’t the only true crime documentary that will leave you guessing. The streaming platform has quite a plethora of documentaries to watch, from Wild Wild Country to Tinder Swindler. We promise you won’t believe what you’re watching is real—these documentaries are that crazy.