If you’re totally over scrolling through gift guides only to see the same five ideas again, these oooh-worthy presents may help you score the kind of surprise that actually delights. We’re talking fun scratch-off date books, whimsical stocking stuffers, cozy pajama gifts, and yummy treats that reviewers swear by. You’ll find unique puzzles, quirky mugs, and gifts from small businesses that feel thoughtful without trying too hard. Ahead: a mix of unexpected treats worth unwrapping