Popular products from this list

Dr. Scholl's loafers because perfection really does exist, and it's both stylish *and* functional. Reviewers can't stop raving about the solid quality and out-of-the-box comfort these shoes provide.

Strappy Plaka sandals that require absolutely *no* break-in time. Take 'em straight out of the box, put them on your feet, and be on your merry way. For reference, these are so great that they garnered over 19,000 positive reviews.

Stretch fabric flip-flops with over 👏 20,000 👏 positive reviews going on and on about how comfy they are. To say these bad boys are loved is pretty much the understatement of the [Zenon: Girl of the] 21st century.

Unless otherwise specified, all sizes in this post are listed in women’s.

1. Toms recycled cotton loafers we're dubbing our favorite travel shoe because not only are these great for hours-long walks through new cities, but they're also excellent for the airport security line — it takes a second to slip 'em off and put 'em back on.

amazon.com, amazon.com

Promising review: "My last pair finally wore out after five years. It was time to get a new pair, and these worked off perfectly. There was very little break in required, and so far they are holding shape and color." —cbausinger

Price: $32 (available in sizes 5–10)

2. Merrell all-terrain hiking shoes you can drag through sleet, rain, and mud with the peace of mind knowing your hooves will remain perfectly comfortable and dry.

amazon.com, amazon.com, amazon.com

Promising review: "These are my second pair of Merrells, the first being 14 years old. As you can see in the picture, they last forever!! My 14-year-old pair is to the left in the above picture [Editor's Note: see third image on the right]. Comfortable from the box, no break-in time needed. I would strongly recommend." —Betty Piazza

Price: $69+ (available in sizes 5–13, wide fits, and 27 colors)

3. A pair of Havaianas flip-flops so durable, they’d likely survive the apocalypse. Invest in a pair of these basics this summer and prepare to wear them for pretty much every summer to follow.

amazon.com, Amazon

Promising review: "This is my second pair (I just wanted another color) and I'm still wearing first pair after five years. They have gone with me camping, beach, on road trips; they're really perfect for anywhere." —PerrBear916

Price: $10+ (available in sizes 6–12 and eight colors)

4. Dr. Scholl's loafers because perfection really does exist, and it's both stylish *and* functional. Reviewers can't stop raving about the solid quality and out-of-the-box comfort these shoes provide.

amazon.com

Promising review: "I have had these shoes for over five years. I used them for work and loved how comfortable they were. I was sad when they finally broke, so I ended up getting the same pair! I 10 out of 10 recommend." —Katie

Price: $35 (available in sizes 6–13, wide sizes, and four colors) 

5. Original Teva sandals crafted with quick-dry technology so you can walk for hours without having to worrying about slippage due to *ahem* sweaty feet.

amazon.com, amazon.com

Promising review: "They work perfectly. I didn’t think I would be able to find another pair of the originals. So thankful Amazon had them!! I lost my pair in a house fire. I had used my lost pair for about 15 years." —Ray Cadwallader

Price: $59.95+ (available in sizes 5–12 and 35 colors/patterns)

6. Columbia waterproof hiking boots because perfection really does exist, and it's both stylish *and* functional. Reviewers can't stop raving about the solid quality, out-of-the-box comfort, and excellent traction that these waterproof babies offer.

amazon.com

Promising review: "I've had these boots for over three years now. I go camping, hiking, and gardening — so these boots are used often. They are comfortable, supportive, and held up great over the years. Very well-made and I would highly recommend." —crystal dodaro

Price: $71.92 (available in sizes 5–12, two widths, and 12 colors) 

7. Splurge-worthy Frye knee-high boots that are pricey, yes, but very much worth it according to reviews. These are designed from premium leather and crafted to last, meaning you won't have to go boot shopping again for a long, long time.

amazon.com, amazon.com

Promising review: "The first time I bought the Melissa boot was used from a thrift store. 10 years later and they're still going strong, other than needing to be resoled, which is to be expected. I just received my new Melissa boots in brown today. They are stunning and every bit as well-made as my old ones. Well worth the price considering how long they last." —Amazon Customer

Price: $189.98+ (available in sizes 5.5–11 and eight colors)

8. Cork sandals with over 60,000 positive ratings and an under-$30 price tag that leaves me with just one question: whatcha waiting for?

amazon.com

Promising review: "I bought my first pair of Cushionaire Lane sandals five years ago. They only just now wore out to the point of being uncomfortable. I’m a teacher and I have arthritis, so I need shoes that are good on my feet and knees. These are the ones!! I’ve tried other brands. These are hands down my favorite. I could walk miles in these shoes." —Lindsey

Price: $29.99+ (available in sizes 5–13, wide sizes, and 26 colors)

9. Skechers slip-on sneakers that can be tossed in the wash when they need a good cleaning and et voila, they'll emerge looking brand spankin' new. Bonus points: the flexible knit fabric means they're easy to pack in a cramped carry-on.

amazon.com

Promising review: "I bought this same shoe five years ago and have worn them almost daily. They are just now starting to look a little worn out, but still very comfortable. I bought the exact same shoe. Same size and color as I had and I couldn’t be happier!" —Amazon Customer

Price: $44.99+ (available in sizes 5–13 and three widths and 24 color combos)

10. Lace-up Puma sneakers with 15,000+ positive ratings for a stylish silhouette made *exponentially* better by a comfy footbed, perfect for miles-long walks.

amazon.com, amazon.com

Promising review: "I bought these shoes in 2018 and they lasted for five years and I've finally decided to repurchase them (and not because they are in bad condition it just feels like it's time). These are so comfy and worth the money. I’ll be back in another five years!" —Glo

Price: $52+ (available in sizes 5.5–11)

11. Strappy Plaka sandals that require absolutely *no* break-in time. Take 'em straight out of the box, put them on your feet, and be on your merry way. For reference, these are so great that they garnered over 19,000 positive reviews.

Amazon

Promising review: "***I'm coming back to this review that I wrote six years ago to say that these are still my favorite go-to sandals. In the past six years, I've worn these to the beach, work, nature trails, walking through water, on vacation to Greece where we walked all day, on a cross-country road trip, ALL throughout my undergrad and grad school days, including while recovering from a shattered kneecap in my last year of grad school. The only reason I'm back on this page now is to buy the same pair again, as the soles are finally worn down enough to warrant replacing." —Amazon Customer

Price: $34.95+ (available in sizes 5–11 and 25 colors)

12. Sloggers gardening shoes for drizzly days spent in your garden, keeping mud off of your heels and toes (and therefore out of your home).

Amazon, amazon.com

Promising review: "Love my new Sloggers. I bought a pair 11 years ago and finally retired them. They are great for working outdoors and for a quick slip-on shoe. Look great." —Dar

Price: $34.99 (available in sizes 6–11 and 31 patterns)

13. Ariat leather Western boots I'd argue are better than a roundtrip ticket to Nashville (no security lines, no having to pay for a carry-on at the gate, etc.). A comfortable, chunky heel coupled with jersey lining, an anti-skid sole, and pull tabs make these knee-highs a dream.

amazon.com

Promising review: "This is my third pair of these exact boots! The last pair lasted eight years of riding two days a week! They fit great and the inside is soft and squishy! A lot of boots are tough on the inside or slippery. These are perfect." —Melissa

Price: $159.95+ (available in sizes 5.5–19.5 and four colors)

14. Ecco Yucatan sandals with a similar grip to your favorite hiking boots, thanks to their rugged sole — but these babies are blissfully *far* more lightweight, perfect for summer activities.

amazon.com

Promising review: "My previous Ecco Yucatans are 5+ years old and still going strong. I have always been impressed with the quality, comfort, and workmanship of Ecco shoes. If you want a long-wearing, supportive, washable sandal you can wear all day every day; this is your shoe." —Mary Dodson Brown

Price: $109.22+ (available in sizes 4–12.5 and 34 color combos)

15. Franco Sarto patent tassel loafers that are the equivalent of blazer in footwear form. These shoes with any outfit = instant polish.

amazon.com, amazon.com

Promising review: "This is my second pair. I bought a pair three years ago, which still looks great. My feet shrank, so I had to go down a size. Other than that, I think I could have worn these for a few more years." —MRZ

Price: $50+ (available in sizes 5–13, wide fits, and 20 colors)

16. A pair of Clarks leather pumps so comfortable, you'll probably forget that yes, these are actually heels and not your favorite sneakers. One reviewer even said, "I can wear these shoes practically daily..." and they'll actually last!

amazon.com

Reviewers recommend going up by half a size.

Promising review: "Love Clarks shoes. Their pumps with platform heel are so comfortable and I always get compliments. I have a very wide foot and the regular width fits me well. I can wear these shoes practically daily and the shoes will last 3+ years." —Pineville

Price: $43.08+ (available in sizes 5–12 and two widths colors)

17. Reebok sneakers for a classic little white kick that will be worn for eons due to a timeless style that fits any scenario, from coffee shop and grocery store runs to your niece's winter dance recital.

amazon.com

Promising review: "These are the best sneakers! They last forever (at least five years!) and are comfortable from the moment you first put them on. Truly think I could not live without 'new' Princesses and 'old' Princesses for outdoor work." —kenphy

Price: $44 (available in sizes 5–12, wide sizes, and five colors)

18. Reef waterproof sandals you can pack for casual sightseeing in the morning and afternoon and fancier, chic evening outings. Consider this the epitome of a "day-to-night" fashion staple and the ideal travel companion.

Amazon, amazon.com

Promising review: "I have had these sandals for a few years now and have loved them since day one! They are so comfortable. I can walk for miles in them. I now have them in six colors. I love my Crocs but these definitely give them a run for their money and are a lot cuter!" —Carrie

Price: $60+ (available in sizes 5–11 and 30 colors)

19. Blundstone Chelsea boots appropriate for any kind of activity; think everything from hiking to grabbing your morning caffeine. These premium leather splurges are water resistant, provide solid traction, and have an ergonomically engineered toe spring and a removable comfort footbed.

Amazon / Via @blundstoneusa

Promising review: "This is my fourth pair of Blundstones. I had my last pair of black Blundstones (500) for about eight years. I still have my brown pair now, going on five years, and they're still as comfortable as ever. I wear them everywhere unless there is a very formal function. The up-front cost may seem steep; however, consider that you will own these for many, many years. I was recently on an airport tram and I overheard a group commenting on my boots. One gentleman also had Blundstones, and we spent the rest of the ride discussing the merits of ownership. I have yet to meet anyone who does not love these boots." —Copper

Price: $199.95+ (available in sizes 6–16 and three colors)

20. New Balance 608 V5 cross trainers becuase you need an easy, everyday shoe that'll match whatever you're wearing (athleisure, jeans, etc.) *and* won't fall apart after a few wears.

amazon.com, amazon.com

Promising review: "I've had mine for over five years. They're still in good shape. I use them for outside and yard work. They are made of thick leather. They protect my feet well and are very comfortable." —Tea

Price: $62.97+ (available in sizes 5–12, three widths, and three colors)

21. Crocs ballet flats you can crown with the title of your new "errands" shoe as they're sleeker than flip-flops but equally as comfortable.

amazon.com

Promising review: "I have several pairs over 10 years old. Very comfortable and my feet love them." —Robyn Brink

Price: $29.99 (available in sizes 4–11 and three colors)

22. Stretch fabric flip-flops with over 👏 20,000 👏 positive reviews going on and on about how comfy they are. To say these bad boys are loved is pretty much the understatement of the [Zenon: Girl of the] 21st century.

amazon.com

Promising review: "Five years later and still a perfect pair of sandals! I am picky about comfortable shoes and these are great! I definitely plan to get a couple of colors." —Amazon Customer

Price: $29.99+ (available in sizes 5–11 and six colors)

23. Chic London Fog rain booties that have me contemplating a cross-country move to Seattle, Washington for an excuse to don these daily. All I want to do is wear. these. boots. and jump! in! puddles!

www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com

Promising review: "I brought these to DC for a wet weekend of sightseeing. Though tennis shoes would be the best option for the amount of walking we did, these were suitably comfortable and kept my feet dry for all seven-plus miles we walked that day. (Not to mention how absolutely adorable they are!) No blisters, no regrets!" —RT

"I had one prior to this for about five years and they served their time.  I love these boots; the color and quality are great, and the softness provides support for your back when standing for long periods of time." —swizzle

Price: $29.95+ (available in sizes 6–11 and 20 styles)

24. Sperry canvas sneakers to give your sneaker collection a summer-inspired upgrade. Who's summering in the Hamptons this summer? Clearly, the answer is you.

amazon.com

Promising review: "I bought a pair of these some six years ago! These are my go-to shoe for just about everyday! I’ve worn them for the last six and they’ve held up! They are now looking worn and hard to clean. I’ve looked in all the stores here and you just can’t find these there. But you can find them here!!! And just about the same price I paid six years ago!! I did have to put an insole in the ones I currently have, and they walk like a dream. Sole is still as good as it was on day one! I love these sneakers!!" —Karleen

Price: $49.99+ (available in sizes 5–12, wide fits, and seven colors)

25. Adidas tennis shoes that are no-frills, no-fuss, and you'll never ever get sick of them. What more can we say? They're everywhere for a reason.

amazon.com

Promising review: "Got it for Europe trip, three weeks. I had my old pair from five years ago, and I love how comfy it is; I wanted a new pair for our vacation. It was comfy, no blisters...It looks good with everything and can go from day to night, even with a dress. I wore it walking the three cities in Cinque Terre, it got dusty but with a little soap and light brush/wash, it looks new again. Highly recommended. I would buy from here again." —ESJ

Price: $70+ (available in sizes 5–11 and 26 colors)

26. Chaco strappy slides with adjustable bands that can conform specifically to your foot, guaranteeing a glove-like fit that reviewers swear will look and feel brand-new for decades.

amazon.com

Promising review: "I had my original Chacos from college (17 years ago). These are my newest pair, and they are super comfy. They are great to wear with socks or tights when I get home. Love them! These are a size 10." —REVS. PAYNE

Price: $30.24+ (available in sizes 5–12 and 23 colors)

27. And finally, a pair of Crocs — because say what you'd like, but these have earned over 630,000 (no, we're not kidding) positive Amazon ratings.

amazon.com

Promising review: "Ugly, weird-looking clown shoes that everyone, including me, loves to make fun of. And yet, within five minutes of getting home for the night, I'm wearing these. They're comfortable, are well ventilated enough to let my feet air out (foot funk is truly nasty), and don't slip off as easily with the strap in back. They're also durable, I've had this pair for five years and while they show some wear, they're still comfortable." —Goth Gone Grey

Price: $34.99+ (available in sizes 4–19 and in 50+ colors) 

Reviews have been edited for length and clarity.