28 Sandals That'll Replace The Pair You Destroyed Last Summer

28 Sandals That'll Replace The Pair You Destroyed Last Summer

BuzzFeed-Shopping·2025-06-06 05:05

Unless otherwise specified, all sizes in this post are listed in women’s.

1. Lace-up wedge sandals that'll help you perfectly recreate Megara's fabulous look from Hercules — and who wouldn't want to look as cool as she does??? They also feature a non-slip rubber sole, so if you fall on your face, that's on YOU, girly.  😂

www.amazon.com

Promising review: "I went dancing in the shoes — great support. They fit well and are comfortable, I felt like I was wearing a pair of sneakers. Great value, quality shoe. I received a lot of compliments. I would buy these shoes again." —Quintilyn M

Get them from Amazon for$39.99+(available in sizes 6–11 and three styles).

2. Stylish slides with double buckles that are more than just a pretty face — they are actually adjustable (gasp!), so even if you typically fall into a "wide foot" range, you can still rock these! 

www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com

Promising review: "I have wider feet, so I usually go for adjustable-strap sandals like these. When I first opened, I noticed the shoes were very light and kind of felt like cardboard, so I immediately thought they were poor quality, but I bought them to wear to work, so I wasn't too concerned because I spend the majority of the day in my office. I took a trip to New Orleans, packing these because they are very cute but was only planning to wear them for dinner. I ended up wearing them all day, two days in a row, and I got about 14–16K steps each day. So comfy the whole time!! My only complaint now is that the straps feel slightly loose, but I've already put a lot of steps in them and have only had them for a month. So it makes sense. I'm assuming tightening the bands can resolve that issue. OVERALL: I recommend these to everyone looking at them!! Cute, inexpensive, and relatively comfy for the price and type of shoe!" —Denise

Get them from Amazon for $26.99+ (available in sizes 6–10, including half sizes, and three styles).

3. Or extra-wide-width strappy sandals you'll enjoy even if you DON'T typically have a wide foot — they're a great travel option if your feet tend to swell while flying. These straps add a little *~somethin' somethin'~* to a typical sandal, don't ya think?

www.amazon.com

Promising reviews: "I purchased these sandals to use at a wedding. I was very happy that these sandals were a little more 'strappy' so it didn’t look like I was wearing flip-flops. I have wide feet that can swell, especially after being on them all day. These sandals were roomy enough to accommodate my feet despite the swelling due to travel. A much better option than having to suffer in heels!" —Skylander

"I NEVER write reviews, BUT in this occasion I had to. My feet NEVER, EVER fit in sandals I buy at stores until these. I wear a size 9 in women's shoes and about a size 10 in sandals. The 10 X-Wide size was perfect as well as the straps. I can’t find anything negative about it! Will order in more colors!" —Lorena

Get them from Amazon for $39.99 (available in extra-wide sizes 7–13 and 10 colors). 

4. Aerothotic flip-flops that'll check every last box on your list of footwear concerns — they have soft straps, serious arch support (shout out to their gel insoles), a sweat-resistant footbed, and come in a bunch of lovely colors! 

www.amazon.com

These have the American Podiatric Medical Association Seal of Acceptance, which is granted to products found to promote good foot health!

Promising review: "I purchased these last summer because they were recommended for plantar fasciitis sufferers and I have not been disappointed! These are casual and perfect for everyday wear and I can wear them for hours and hours of walking without any discomfort. I really am happy with these flip-flops!" —INcatlady

Get them from Amazon for $38.99 (available in sizes 6–11 and 22 colors). 

5. Double-buckle slides for anyone who adores the look of Birkenstocks but has a more *~footloose and fancy-free ~* style when it comes to their footwear choices. These are just as comfortable but come in some more playful styles.

www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com

Promising review: "Got these as house sandals to keep my feet off the tile floor. It feels like walking around on one of those kitchen mats; I love them. So much easier (and less hot) than putting on sneakers. I've gotten them muddy in the yard, and they wash up nicely. They fit my wide feet and high arches great. Never did I expect to buy sandals online and have them fit and be comfortable, but here we are" —BlueSkies

Get them from Amazon for$25.49+ (available in women's sizes 6–11 and dozens of colors). 

6. Some slip-on platform wedges in case you're hoping to literally elevate your style, starting with your spring/summer shoes. Chunky espadrille sandals are exactly what you need to kickstart your warm-weather fashion overhaul — they're so comfortable one reviewer even boasted about being able to limbo in them.  😅

www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com

Promising review: "These are one of my better purchases on Amazon. They are cute and comfortable, like walking on a cloud. They are not heavy or clunky. They are light but sturdy. They can be worn with so many outfits because of their neutral color."  —Lynette Robotti

Get them from Amazon for $40.59+ (available in sizes 6–10 and seven colors).

7. Strappy chunky heels with a square toe that'll make you wanna show off those tootsies from dawn to dusk. They're super versatile, come in so many fun shades, and will take you straight to Compliment City the next time you wear 'em around your friends. 

www.amazon.com

Promising reviews: "Reaching for these sandals more and more because they’re comfy, cute, and elevate my outfits! They didn’t require any breaking in and I’ve worn them for an entire day out and had no issues with long term wear. Fit was true to size. Going to get another color since I love them so much!" —Nidhi Patel

Get them from Amazon for $29.99+ (available in sizes 6–10 and 26 styles). 

8. Or a flat braided pair in case you love the *lewk* but have zero interest in wearing heels all day (I certainly couldn't!). These give off high-end energy but are so affordable you won't cry into your rosé if you spill something on them.

www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com

Promising review: "The pink looks great on my skin tone. I have very wide feet, and these sandals stretch as you walk, which is wonderful, but they also don’t slip out. Will buy in other colors!" —Marline Pena

Get them from Amazon for $26.98+ (available in sizes 6–11 and 10 colors).

9. Steve Madden slides you'll happily slip in and out of all summer long whether you're planning to take a midday stroll or are off to a pal's to enjoy a daiquiri by the pool. Cheers to you and your new shoes, dahhhhling.

Heather Braga / BuzzFeed, Amazon

I've been living in these shoes for YEARS. I have them in black and they are one of my tried-and-true favorites. They're just the perfect basic sandal! They look great with dresses, jeans, and leggings which is pretty much all I ask for in a summer shoe. Check the image (left) above to see me wearing them with both a dress and jeans. Since they are open-backed there is no chance of uncomfortable rubbing. I just love 'em.

Promising review: "This shoe is so cute for how cheap it is!! I would definitely suggest sizing at least a half size up. I usually wear 6 or 7 in shoes and I got this sandal in a 7.5 and it fits just right. I maybe could have even gotten an 8. Overall, it’s a perfect shoe for a warm spring/summer day!" —Morgan

Get them from Amazon for $54.95(available in sizes 5–11 and 11 styles).

10. Cushioned sandals featuring thick straps and a supportive sole for those occasions where you want to rock cute footwear but also would rather not end up with blisters galore.

www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com

Promising review: "I absolutely love these sandals. They are incredibly comfy and fit well. I have semi-narrow feet and these do not feel too loose. The elastic in the straps is soft, so even if they fit a bit tighter, I feel like they would still be comfortable. I plan on buying these in a few colors! :)" —Elaura

Get them from Amazon for $22.49+ (available in sizes 6–11 and eight styles)

11. Simple leather slides you can count on to go with *everything* and never go out of style — you truly can't go wrong investing in a pair of these bad boys.

Christina Christi / Etsy

Christina Christi is a woman-owned small businesses that handcrafts all of her jewelry, bags, and sandals in Athens, Greece.

Promising review: "Love these sandals, good fit, beautifully made, and they arrived so quickly. I would definitely buy from Christina again." —karengazz

Get them from Christina Christi on Etsy for $98.04 (available in sizes 5–10.5 and two colors).

12. Handmade leather sandals with a minimalist look to them that'll leave you reaching for them over and over. The leather insoles will soften over time so, just like your favorite bottle of wine, these will get better with age.

Light Bleu / Etsy

Light Bleu is a small business based in Greece specializing in handmade leather accessories focusing on quality pieces at affordable prices. 

Promising reviews: "I love the quality of the sandals. I walked in them for hours and hours, and it did not hurt at all. The owner was amazing. I ordered the wrong size, and they immediately took care of it. I’ve never had that kind of experience with a seller. I highly recommend this seller to everyone. Thank you again." —Nina

Get them from Light Bleu on Etsy for $31.37 (available in sizes 4.5–12 and five colors). 

13. Classic jelly sandals you'll get tons of praise for since they are totally having *a moment* right now. Go ahead and relive your childhood even though you're an adult with a full-time job and bills. 

www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com

Promising review: "These jellies are some of the best I’ve had. The plastic is soft, malleable, and easy to walk in. In other shoes, I’m a 7.5/8, so I ordered a size 8, and they fit perfectly. The heel is hollow, and the shoe is lightweight, as opposed to other brands." —Amazon Customer

Get them from Amazon for $16.99+ (available in sizes 5–9 and 35 styles).

14. Colorful Tevas for anyone who *already* has a pair they've loved and adored so much that they're basically in shambles — treat yourself to new ones this summer so you can get back to traipsing along a rocky trail without the need to break out sneakers.

www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com

Promising review: "I love the '90s vibe and they are super comfortable. Went on a two-mile walk the first day I got them and had no issues. I was worried about them rubbing my pinky toe, but they didn’t. I’ll definitely be wearing them all summer." —P Robinson

Get them from Amazon for $44.99+ (available in sizes 5–13 and a ton of styles).

15. Squishy slide-on slippers that are primarily meant to be worn at home — and that's OK because they're so ridiculously comfortable you won't want to risk wearing them outdoors too much. These delectable little marshmallow–like slip-ons must be protected at all costs!

www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com

FYI: Many reviewers suggest sizing down!

Promising review: "These slides are — and I mean this in the best way — marshmallows that mold to your individual feet. They are SOOOO comfortable. I’ve been working from home since the start of the pandemic, and I ordered them to wear in my house after I read that walking around barefoot long-term isn’t great for your feet. I wanted something with a little support but that would be comfortable. The reviews for these looked good so I ordered a pair, and now I never want to take them off. The material in every part is molded and squishy so there are no unexpected parts that dig into your skin or chafe. But they’re structured enough to provide some support for your arches. 10/10 highly recommend!" —Carrie B

Get them from Amazon for $23.99+ (available in sizes 4–16 and 15 styles).

16. Chunky sandals for all my '90s babies who are still not over the return of this trend — the chunky heel and platform sole will take your style *~to the next level~* while paying homage to the ones you used to run around in during the summer of 1998. 

www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com

Promising review: "Stretchy material on the top, and true to size. (I am a 9 or 9.5) There isn't much traction on the bottom, so it is a bit slippery on hardwood at first. After a dull day of wearing them, my feet do not hurt, the slippery bottom did get better, and they have better traction on them now. No blisters. Love the platform and they are lightweight, not heavy or clunky to walk in. Easy to walk in when bending your foot. The cushion is comfy. Great quality. I recommend these shoes!" —Brooke Crump

Get them from Amazon for $39.99 (available in sizes 6–11 and in taupe weave). 

17. Block-heel sandalswith a stylish slingback design that'll replace the basic pair you wore down into the ground while parading through countless weddings and baby showers last summer.

Nisolo

Promising review: "Beautiful! True to size and so comfortable! No break-in time needed! Love the leather! These will be my "go-to"! Worth every penny!" —Tracy C

Get them from Nisolo for$149 (originally $170, available in sizes 5–11 and four styles).

18. Reef two-strap sandals that'll make you stop what you're doing the second you try 'em on so you can call your bestie and tell her you've found your sole-mate. They're made of vegan leather and have cushy, rubber sole that'll make you feel more supported than ever.

www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com

Promising review: "I purchased these to wear on vacation a few times. Little did I know that I would live in them for the entire vacation in Puerto Rico. I then wore them every day in Disney for six days straight, and I was the only one in our party not to complain about sore feet and the wrong shoes." —J. Malone

"I have plantar fasciitis and these are the only sandals I can wear all day, every day. I'm on my feet anywhere between 8–13 hours a day. These are fabulous." —Stacey

Get them from Amazon for $59.95+ (available in sizes 5–11 and 28 colors).

19. Classic Adidas slides you've likely coveted since your teen years when all the cool athletes wore them throughout the halls on game days (couldn't possibly just be my school, right?), Anyways, they're perfect for slipping on in a hot second when your dog is begging to go out, for a jaunt in Target, or to grab a quick coffee.

www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com

Promising review: "I bought these because I like to wear them when I'm at home lounging around. These sandals are comfortable and I can wear them for hours without my wide feet hurting." —RoseO

Get them from Amazon for $22.90+ (available in women's sizes 5–19, men's sizes 4–18, and many colors).

20. Braided Plaka sandals for anyone who has always prided themselves on curating a flawless boho look and making it seem effortless. The straps on these beauties are adjustable, so no need to fret over any potential rubbing!

www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com

FYI, these are best suited for narrow to medium-sized feet. 

Promising reviews: "I literally got compliments on them everywhere we went, and they were so comfortable I could wear them all day walking miles and miles through the streets of New Orleans, and my feet didn't hurt (and that's a small miracle given I have arthritis). They are surprisingly durable, and the woven fabric tops are incredibly soft and comfy. Even when my feet swelled due to the heat and humidity in New Orleans, these were still pretty darn comfy as compared to other shoes I brought along on the trip." —UrbanUtah

"These sandals are like cotton candy clouds for your feet. Basically the Rolls-Royce of sandals." —A. Alphonse

Get them from Amazon for $34.95 (available in sizes 5–11 and 25 colors).

21. Elastic strap sandals you'll love as much as your favorite pair of leggings — and for similar reasons! They're super stretchy and will perfectly fit around your feet without digging in like a toddler who was just given an ice cream sundae. You're going to love wearing these everywhere and anywhere!

www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com

Promising review: "These shoes are perfect, true to size, cute, and stretchy. I was hesitant to buy shoes online, but these sandals are such a good buy for the price. I wore them all day at the zoo (I walked for four hours) and had no issues. Highly recommend." —Rosemary Ingar

Get them from Amazon for $18.89+ (available in sizes 5–11, including half sizes, and 12 colors).

22. Faux leather slip-ons with Hermès vibes (ooh, la la) because you deserve to feel fancy-schmancy without dumping your entire savings into a shoe purchase. The H-shape is timeless and will pair beautifully with all of your go-to summer looks, I promise.

www.amazon.com, Amazon

Reviewers do recommend sizing up (especially if you're between sizes) as they run a bit small!

Promising review: "Love these! Super comfortable and the leather isn’t overly shiny (making them look super fake). I’m on my feet all day at work and needed a summer alternative. So far, so good. Definitely recommend, especially for the price." —Amazon Customer

Get them from Amazon for $18.59+ (available in sizes 6–11 and eight colors).

23. Sorel Kinetic sandals I can honestly imagine wearing when we all finally make the move to living on the space station with Zenon. Zetus lapetus, these shoes are so cute!

www.amazon.com, Sorel

Promising reviews: "This is my fourth pair of these shoes. So hard to wear anything else. They’re great for shorts, pants, skirts, and dresses. Funky style with unbeatable comfort. I’ve probably walked 1,000 miles (5–10 miles at a time) in my first pair and no blisters." —LSCool

"If there were ever a marriage between sandals and athletic shoes, this was their baby. It’s super comfortable, it adapts to different foot widths, it has a perfect platform, which not only adds an inch and a half to your height but also has grip, making you feel secure every time you take a step. It has great arch support and, on top of everything, they look gorgeous on your feet." —Isabella

Get them from Amazon for $136.36+ (available in sizes 5–12 and 11 colors).

24. Skechers rhinestone slingbacks that'll prove once and for all that shoes can be practical and dazzling simultaneously. These bejeweled beauties have a stretchy back strap to keep 'em in place and a yoga foam base that'll make you feel like you're walking on clouds.

www.amazon.com

Promising reviews: "These Sketchers with yoga foam are incredibly comfortable. I wore them and walked almost 5 miles yesterday, and they were amazing! I also love the bling, as they can be worn for a fancy meal or out and about to a bazaar. I will definitely be buying another pair!" —Quilts2theHilt

"Love these! Very pretty and sooooo comfy! I can wear these while walking for hours and be fashionable at the same time!" —Dee

Get them from Amazon for $30.95+ (available in sizes 5–11, including wide sizes, and seven colors).

25. Crocs platform wedges, you'll take one look at 'em and be like, "No waaaaay, these are related to those clogs," and yet, they certainly are! Reviewers rave about how walkable they are and love wearing them while traveling.

www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com

BuzzFeed Shopping editor Chelsea Stuart says, "These may just be my favorite sandals ever. I am a big platform person so that's what initially sold me but better yet, they're just so freaking comfortable. They have a slight bounce and the straps do. not. rub. so I can wear them for hours on end. Since they're plastic, they can also get wet without issue and they dry off super fast. If you're on the fence because you're a Never Croc-er™ just give 'em a try."

Promising review: "If you are looking for a cute and comfortable shoe, look no further! This shoe is everything! I wore this shoe all day long walking through the streets of Paris and Florence. And when I say walk, I mean walk...some days up to 10 miles. I brought three other pairs of shoes and ended up wearing these pretty much every day. The platform heel was just the right height, and the sole was almost like memory foam and seemed to absorb the pressure from all the standing and walking. The straps did not rub my feet and were easy to open, close, and adjust. Great shoe if you are on the go! I would highly recommend." —Jay

Get them from Amazon for $48.94+ (available in sizes 4–11 and 16 styles). 

26. Supportive hiking sandals to help you channel your inner Sporty Spice without sacrificing your personal style. The braided straps are so fun (and adjustable!), and the entire shoe has been designed around arch support. The next time someone says, "Take a hike!" you can say, "I THINK I JUST MIGHT!"

www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com

Promising review: "These cute sandals are like walking on clouds. They have fantastic arch support (like Birkenstocks), and are light and flexible. I will be buying them in other colors, for sure. They are cute with a casual dress, or you can wear them with shorts, yoga pants, or jeans — very versatile. I am a standard 6.5 and I bought a 6, which fits perfectly. I also have slightly wide feet and these fit great. They truly fit like a glove." —Derek VanHoose

Get them from Amazon for $31.10+ (available in sizes 6–11 and 17 colors).

27. Dr. Martens fisherman sandals because why should you only be able to rock your favorite brand of shoes during the cooler seasons? These will help you transition out of your badass boots during the hot summer months.

www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com

Many reviewers suggest sizing down as the straps can feel a bit loose.

Promising review: "First and foremost, these sandals are SO cute and SO comfortable. They have padding on the ankle straps, which really reduces the likelihood of getting blisters. I have pretty 'thick' feet and the straps around the feet are still large on me so I do feel that they run big. I was also shocked at how lightweight these are; like walking on clouds!" —Gabrielle

Get them from Amazon for $45.20+ (available in sizes 5–11).

28. And Sanuk Yoga Mat flip-flops you'll be so impressed by — they're literally crafted from the same yoga mat material you collapse onto and stare at the ceiling after an intense session (that's the best part of any class, IMO). The material is super grippy so if you're prone to sweaty feet you won't have to think twice about slipping and sliding while you're out and about.

www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com

Promising review: "I CANNOT RAVE ENOUGH ABOUT THIS FLIP-FLOP!! I spend two weeks in Bali and walked / traveled soooo much and these were what I loved in! They are the most comfortable shoe I have ever worn in my life, period. They are durable, like walking on a cloud, so incredibly wonderfully light, great for the beach, great for walking, I even did some form of hiking in them. Not kidding, these saved my life. I don’t know what I would have done without them. My partner had blisters from her Rainbow sandals, which cost way more than these and weren’t nearly as comfortable. A must buy!" —samantha

Get them from Amazon for $34.95+ (available in sizes 5–11 and in 14 styles).

Reviews have been edited for length and/or clarity.

……

Read full article on BuzzFeed-Shopping

Lifestyle Fashion