38 “Too Good To Be True” Products That Proved Reviewers Wrong In A Big Way
BuzzFeed and our publishing partners may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page. Read More
Maybe you didn’t always believe in this sweat-activated dry shampoo and customizable memory foam pillow, but they sure believed in you.
Posted on Oct 31, 2026 UTC
by Emma Lord BuzzFeed BuzzFeed Staff
As a Senior Shopping Writer at BuzzFeed, I specialize in a broad range of topics, including beauty, cleaning, fashion, personal care, home, fitness, and my beloved “TikTok made me buy it.” My work has been featured across lifestyle and writing publications during my ten years in the digital media space, including Bustle, HuffPost, HelloGiggles, and The Washington Post.
Learn more about different kinds of eye drops and what they can do at Cleveland Clinic. Note that eye drops can potentially mask symptoms of eye conditions, so you should talk to your eye doctor about what's right for you. And according to Mayo Clinic, you should avoid redness-reducing drops if you're looking for dry eye relief.
Check out a TikTok of the Lumify eye dropsin action.
Promising review: "I have a big spot of blood vessels in the inner corner of my left eye. I use the expensive lubricant eye drops for moisture — I've used Visine, Clear Eyes, you name it. No eye drop has made my eyes look this great. Only Lumify! I was soo happy when I looked in the mirror and saw some beauty in my eyes instead of darkness and redness." —Angela Leonard
Get it from Amazon for $11.93.
Promising review: "I saw this product on TikTok and decided to try it out for myself. The name doesn’t lie — spray it on, shut the bathroom door, and in a few hours, the shower is 100 times cleaner. Usually, I’ll let it sit overnight, and by morning, the visible grime on the shower is gone, including soap scum. I’ll usually let the shower water rinse the residue out, and then I will take a bucket just to get everything off the shower walls. It is a bit slick if you try to get in the shower without rinsing the residue, but otherwise it’s a worthy cleaning staple in my house." —Tara D.
This is one of our 2026 Buzzy Award winners! Check out the full list to shop all 100 picks, hand-selected by the BuzzFeed Shopping team.
Get it from Amazon for $19.99 (available in two scents and two sizes).
Promising review: "This stuff is where it's at for dry, wrinkled neck skin. I'm noticing a real difference after using it faithfully for two weeks. My skin on my neck is smoother and tighter. Please try it out." —Treva Burke
Get it from Amazon for $11.97.
Promising review: "I bought this foot mask after seeing it on TikTok, and I was a little hesitant to order it from Amazon because I’ve heard there are a lot of fakes out there. But this one is definitely the real deal! It worked really well and did exactly what I expected. I’m really happy with my purchase and would definitely recommend it." —Merv
Get two pairs from Amazon for $15.99.
www.amazon.com, Amazon
Promising review: "I wish I could give this 10 stars. I would have never believed that a cloth and plain water could get my windows so clean. After years of struggling with streaks, blurry areas, etc. I was skeptical this would work. So I followed the short instructions (wet, wring, wipe) and stood back. I still saw dirt and spots, and was about to think 'yep, too good to be true,' but then realized I had not wiped the other side. Repeated the cleaning and then... shock. A sparkling clean window with nothing to be annoyed about to re-clean. I did this to three huge windows and got the same results. Wife came home and was like, 'Wow, never seen these windows that clean.' On a fourth window, I tried with a clean (non-E-cloth) cloth + Windex, then with vinegar. Nope, not good enough. Then with E-cloth, I got the same result. AMAZING product and very eco-friendly, down to the packaging." —Sitarix
Get it from Amazon for$14.99 (available in six colors).
www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com
Check out a TikTok of the Retinal Skin Booster in action.
Promising review: "Almost two weeks and my skin has been doing great! I replaced my AHA toner from Paula’s Choice with this and found that it has been more gentle and made my skin glow immediately the next morning. I still like my AHA toner, but this really helped with my pores and skin texture. I used tretinoin before, and I found that it was harder to spread. The consistency of this formula made it so easy to spread on my face and neck! Not to mention the price is a steal! Loving this product so much! I am acne-prone (hormonal acne around the jaw) with combination skin (very oily and very dry), and this really helped even out everything." —T.
Get it from Amazon for $19.99.
This shampoo was designed to work for sensitive scalps, color-dyed, and chemically processed hair, as well as for all hair types and textures, with reviewers with 3b–4c curls mentioning it worked for them.
Promising review: "I was hesitant. I have been dealing with dandruff for almost 10 years, fortunately, not that heavy, but enough where it was embarrassing. I tried everything. Leave-in conditioner, tea tree oil, Head and Shoulders, etc. One brand did work for a couple of days, but that's it. But this product has worked EFFECTIVELY. Dandruff-free for two months so far. It can leave your hair feeling a little dry, so just use conditioner, and it will balance out. If other products aren't working for you with dandruff, I can confidently recommend this one." —Martin C.
Get it from Amazon for $16.88.
www.amazon.com, Jenae Sitzes/BuzzFeed
The color-adaptive formula is designed so that one of five shades will work on any skin tone.
Promising review: "Took years off my eyes! This product is so reasonably priced. I came across a TikTok promoting this and decided to take a chance since the price was super reasonable. My eyes looked brighter in a good way, and the concealer worked so well that I felt I looked younger. I got compliments from friends asking what I did differently with my makeup. I recommend it." —Monica T.
Get it from Amazon for $6 (available in five shades).
www.amazon.com, Amazon
Promising review: "This product, my drill, and the flat sponge type cleaning pad were the only things that worked, transforming this very dirty tub into cleaner than clean. Very little muscle power necessary. A little goes a long way. It takes off the worst of things and leaves a kind of ceramic coat behind. It’s amazing." —Glinda
Get it from Amazon for $5.97.
www.amazon.com, Amazon
Promising review: "The mascara and the bristles on the brush are top tier! I love this mascara! It’s the perfect consistency, no clumping, buildable, and no flaking. The brush/bristles are sturdy and create the perfect lashes. This mascara gives great length, definition, and bold color. All day wear, and it doesn’t damage your lashes when it comes to washing off or using makeup remover at the end of the day. Nice-sized tube as well. I will definitely buy this mascara again. A bit pricey but totally worth it." —Megan Y
Get it from Amazon for $28 (available in black and brown).
www.amazon.com, Amazon
Check out a TikTok of the marshmallow lip treatmentin action.
Promising review: "My new must-have! My number one go-to for healing lips was Carmex. This beat it. I love the consistency (very creamy/smooth), it’s not heavily flavored or goopy, and it obviously smells amazing. It isn’t overbearing and also doesn’t keep coating your mouth like the Eos stick balms (still great, but more wax)." —Breanah Shirazi
Get it from Amazon for $5.99 (also available in Strawberry Acai).
Promising review: “AMAZING!!! I followed the directions exactly and saw results within a week! My big toe has been in bad shape for about eight years. It is quickly changing the color of my toenail back to normal, my nail is becoming thin again, and the curve in my nail is moving back to its normal position. I HIGHLY recommend this product! I can’t wait to see the final result once I complete the process. Don’t hesitate, JUST GET IT!!" —Mariaelena
Get it from Amazon for $19.97+ (also available with nail files).
Amazon, www.amazon.com
Check out a TikTok of the Laneige Neo Blurring Powder in action.
Promising review: "I loved this setting powder; it blurred my pores and blended my makeup so well that even my husband noticed. Wow! I will be buying more before people find it and sell it all out, hehehe." —Charlotte Laim
This is one of our 2026 Buzzy Award winners! Check out the full list to shop all 100 picks, hand-selected by the BuzzFeed Shopping team.
Get it from Amazon for $25.
Promising review: "My favorite dry shampoo! It smells great and truly is sweat-activated. I wear it during some heavy workouts, and I can smell it, and it helps keep my hair from being greasy if I have plans after." —Marianna Stutts
Get it from Amazon for $9.98+ (available in two sizes).
Promising review: "This product actually works! Very affordable, too. There are a lot of expensive teeth whitening products out there, but why spend extra money when you don't have to? Definitely worth trying!" —Mona L Cureton
Get a two-pack from Amazon for $9.95.
www.amazon.com, Amazon
Check out a TikTok of the serum in action.
Promising review: "Literally, the best hair product you can possibly get that is affordable and doesn’t leave your hair greasy — it makes it shiny and super soft. After I get out of the shower, when my hair is still damp, I put some on my ends and work the rest up into the top of my head. Sometimes I blow my hair dry after I get out of the shower and put it on, and then after I blow dry it, I put some more on, and it looks absolutely beautiful — no greasy hair here. My hair type is fine and gets oily really fast, and yet somehow this product tames it a bit and keeps it looking healthy for days! Will purchase again and again!!!" —Tara Klein
Get it from Amazon for $15.86+ (available in two sizes, a mist style, and four other formulas).
www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com
Promising review: "I've seen these leggings all over TikTok and finally decided to give them a chance. I do a lot of HIIT workouts and find that these 'buttery soft' leggings never really hold up well. I don't know what they're doing differently here, but I love it. They are so soft and stretchy, but incredibly smooth. They've done well in HIIT, low-impact, and weight-lifting workouts. I couldn't recommend these enough." —Ashley
"These leggings are incredible! The fabric is so soft and feels just like Lululemon. Lightweight, high-quality, and sweat‑wicking. Even during intense workouts or runs, I don’t feel sweaty at all. They move perfectly with my body and stay in place without riding down. Definitely my new favorite pair!" —Kara
Get them from Amazon for $32 (available in women's sizes XXS–XL and 29 colors) — and check out matching tops and bras at the Amazon CRZ Yoga page!
www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com
You can use this for your face and neck, or even use it on your under-eyes to de-puff and help prevent dark circles!
Promising review: "The holy grail. Caved because I saw this on TikTok. I am SO impressed, literally my first time using it, and the results are surreal. Incredible product!!!! Literally Botox in a bottle. My skin is smooth, soft, and so glowy on top of the wrinkle-reducing effect." —Jenny Skinner
Get it from Amazon for $15.20.
Promising review: "I’ve tried Toppik before, but I actually prefer this so much more! It does a great job filling in thinner areas along my hairline and makes my hair look fuller without leaving behind that powdery residue or buildup I get with Toppik. I also love that I can use it to fill in my eyebrows, so it’s basically two products in one. It looks natural, is easy to apply, and a little goes a long way. Definitely one of my favorite products for making my hair look thicker!" —Bella
Get it from Amazon for $17.95 (available in 14 shades and two sizes).
www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com
Check out a TikTok of the Tumella Umbrella in action.
I am originally from Seattle, so I hate umbrellas of all kinds!! But I bought this one on Prime Day because the only way to take my baby out in the rain in NYC is to wear him in a carrier and hold an umbrella above us. This thing is HARDY. We have had some of the biggest, wildest winds and sideways rain in New York this summer, and this thing never flinches. I also ADORE the instant open with a button, which I only have to use one hand for. It's super compact and slides easily back into its waterproof cover to store for later. I can't believe how affordable this umbrella is, given how well it holds up and how well it's designed!
Promising review: "Why would anyone want to purchase another umbrella with the warranty this one gives? Not like you will need the warranty with this build quality. Almost every umbrella I have owned has five, maybe six, thin metal rods held together with a tiny pin to form the frame. This thing has reinforced ribs, is as light as you can get, looks great, and all at a low price. Yeah, this is all I need." —E. Smoker
Get it from Amazon for $17.99+ (available in 25 colors and packs of two).
www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com
Promising review: "I have been looking for an azelaic acid product that works for my skin because I heard it does wonders for redness. Well, this product was the answer to my prayers. Holy grail. Will never allow myself to run out. Itis light on the skin and easy to layer other products on top without feeling heavy. It has minimized my facial redness from acne marks and rosacea irritation. While also hydrating my skin instead of irritating it further." —Kimberly B.
Get it from Amazon for$22.
www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com
Promising review: "I absolutely love this collagen overnight mask! I apply it before going to bed and let it work overnight. In the morning, I peel it off and my skin looks so fresh, smooth, and glowing. I love how nice my skin looks when I wake up! This has definitely become one of my favorite skincare products. If you’re thinking about trying it, you won’t regret it!" —Jackie Montanez
Get it from Amazon for $14.20.
Promising review: "NEVER GETTING MY NAILS PROFESSIONALLY DONE AGAIN. I love having long nails. I do not like spending fifty bucks just to get them painted. I tried the gel polish with gel top coat, I tried the gel system with the lamps, and I tried every polish out there. My hands get washed hundreds of times daily. This stuff is unbelievable. It really works the way they say it does. I applied it about one or two minutes after finishing a second coat of color, and within minutes, it had bonded and set, and my nails stayed shiny and polished for over a week. That is not the full two weeks claimed, but I am unusually hard on my nails, so over a week is AWESOME. I immediately ordered several more." —Amazon Customer
Get it from Amazon for $7.25.
Promising review: "This eyeliner is unreal. Black eyeliner is a big part of my signature look, and I've been using the Smashbox gel eyeliner pencil for at least 10 years, and I thought it was the best. I am a complete convert. It's much less expensive, goes on like butter, is super SUPER pigmented, and doesn't budge even the slightest bit. I'm thrilled!" —Julie
Get it from Amazon for $18(available in 12 shades).
Amazon, www.amazon.com
Promising review: "I absolutely love this product. I saw it on TikTok and figured I would give it a try. My grandmother passed away almost eight years ago, and she left me her first engagement ring in her will. I have tried so many jewelry cleaners, toothpaste and toothbrush, you name it, tried everything except for sending it away to get cleaned. I ordered the Diamond Dazzle Stik on Thursday, and it arrived the following Saturday, fast shipping! Today is Sunday, and I cleaned my ring with the Diamond Dazzle Stik. My ring is just as shiny as it was when my grandfather bought it for my grandmother many, many years ago. I will definitely use this Diamond Dazzle Stik on all my jewelry. Highly recommended!" —Heather
Get it from Amazon for $9.48+ (available in two sizes and multipacks).
www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com
Promising review: "Been using this product for a couple of weeks now and I’ve seen a massive decrease in my clogged pores! My face has also felt less greasy in general! Highly recommend!" —Henrie
Get it from Amazon for $15.
www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com
Check out a TikTok of the Medicube PDRN Collagen Volume Stick in action.
Promising review (for the PDRN collagen stick): "After having my son, my under eyes looked hollow and tired no matter how much sleep I got, how much water I drank, or what concealer I used. I've been using the Medicube PDRN Pink Collagen Volume Multi Balm consistently for 30 days on my under-eyes, forehead, 11 lines, and smile lines, and the difference has been remarkable. The biggest improvement has been my under-eye area. The skin looks noticeably more plump, hydrated, and smooth. Not only has the texture improved, but the loss of volume that was making me look constantly exhausted has improved significantly as well." —TutyRu18
Get it from Amazon for $19.90.
www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com
Each cleaner comes with a trial size of Bissell's Spot & Stain Formula, which is also available on Amazon!
Promising review: "Yup, saw it on TikTok and had to buy it. My car's upholstery was so dirty from my dogs and years of NOT getting it deep cleaned. This is a game changer. I should've taken a before and after because it was awesome. Not to mention how satisfying it is to see the dirty water get sucked back into the tank. Easy to prep. Easy to use. Easy to clean. I definitely recommend. This will be perfect for other things in the house as well because if it can tackle MY car with two big dogs, it's gold." —Taylor L.
This mini version of this is one of our 2026 Buzzy Award winners! Check out the full list to shop all 100 picks, hand-selected by the BuzzFeed Shopping team.
Get it from Amazon for $99.99.
Quick & Clean is a small business that specializes in coffee machine cleaning products.
Promising review: "I had no idea that cleaning a Keurig was a thing. I bought these because I saw them on TikTok, believe it or not. I wanted to give it a go because my Keurig isn’t that old and I didn’t think it would do anything. IT WORKS SO WELL! My Keurig wasn’t as nasty as some I’ve seen, lucky. I would highly recommend, keeps everything running correctly and clean." —Lauren
Get a set of six from Amazon for $9.99 (available in three pack sizes).
www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com
Promising review: "Job well done! If you struggle with frequent drain clogs like I do, I highly recommend this product. It’s easy to use, effective, and a great value for the price. The hook design lets me reach deep into the drain and pull out a surprising amount of hair and debris." —Rose
Get a set of four from Amazon for $6.99+ (available in packs of six).
Check out a TikTok of the laundry spray in action.
Puracy is a Texas-based, family-owned business specializing in plant-based, chemical-free, hypoallergenic home products, with a donation made to local families in need with a portion of every purchase.
Psst — this spray also does a number on all those other miscellaneous stains in your life, like wine, coffee, soy sauce, makeup, and period blood! I recently bought this to test it for myself, and can attest to how well it works to get period blood out even after you've tried something else. I stained a pair of beloved bright-blue bike shorts in my sleep and tried to get it out with soap and water, but the stain was still there when it came out of the wash. I treated it with this, stuck it back in the wash, and BOOM, it's like it never happened (I panicked before I could get a before and after, please forgive me, laundry gods).
This is one of our 2026 Buzzy Award winners! Check out the full list to shop all 100 picks, hand-selected by the BuzzFeed Shopping team.
Get it from Amazon for $13.98+ (available in different sizes).
WE SUPPORT A BEAUTIFUL LIE!!
Promising review: "It’s a little hard to squeeze, but that totally makes up for the AMAZING results. I was embarrassed about our tubs because the people we bought our house from didn’t caulk or seal them properly, and this resulted in mildew buildup. I tried EVERYTHING until I saw this on TikTok, I believe — MIRACLE FREAKING WORKER. I will be buying more, the only complaint I will ever have is the shipping got mixed up, but that is not a problem and was fixed very easily!" —Brooklyn Nguyen
Get it from Amazon for $14.99.
www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com
Check out a TikTok of the Shapermint jelly bra in action.
Promising review: "As someone who needs full coverage, I know that finding a wireless option that actually lifts without digging in is rare. The cups are lightweight and molded, giving a natural lift. The sides come up higher, which helps with shaping and keeps everything in place. The fabric is SO soft and breathable. It also has a unique back design with a lot of hooks, and that makes it feel very secure. When I saw the back, I thought it might feel bulky, but it lies flat and smooths the whole back area. It also stays invisible under clothes." —Connie Gonzalez
Get it from Amazon for $19.99 (available in two colors and women's sizes S–4X, or 30C–46DDD/F; check the size chart on the product page for your best fit).
Amazon
SweatBlock is a small business that specializes in antiperspirant products.
Psst — you should definitely "patch test" this on a small area of skin before putting it on to ensure you don't have any reaction!
Promising review: "Was pretty skeptical. Bought it and it’s changed my life. First use and I did not sweat, at all, for probably a week. I had already been using Lume deodorant for a few years now and was looking for something else as I felt I was building a resistance to it. I should’ve been using this to begin with. Second application, I applied to other areas of my body, zero sweat. Amazed." —Hanna L. Hetz
Get a 10-pack from Amazon for $19.99 (each box lasts two months).
Check out this TikTok of the Folex Carpet Spot Removerto see it in action!
Promising review: “I have used Folex for years, and it works wonders on everything from spilled coffee, wine, and dog messes, without any chemical smells or residue. But my love for Folex grew so much deeper when I dropped a 32-ounce jar of salsa down the stairs. My husband took one look and declared that the stairs were ruined and would need to be replaced. I took a look, grabbed the Folex, and said, 'We’ve got this.' If you have children, pets, or are very clumsy with your canned goods, you need this bulk-size jug in your arsenal of cleaning supplies.” —Carobnty
Get it from Amazon for $26.99.
Promising review: "This oven cleaner works very well and removes grease and burned-on food with minimal scrubbing. I like that it is fume-free, easy to apply, and the pro-size can last a long time. Great product for deep cleaning." —Yaini Brigeo
Get it from Amazon for $10.98.
www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com
Bug Bite Thing is a family-owned small business established in 2017 that specializes in bug bite relief products.
This works on mosquitoes, bees, wasps, biting flies, sea lice, and more (although TBH, if this list of bugs gets any longer I may just stay indoors forever!!).
Promising review: "I cannot stress to you enough how much better this simple little tool has made my quality of life during summer in Ohio. It rains a lot. There are a lot of mosquitoes. I have horrific allergic reactions to mosquito bites. We're talking bumps swelling to the width of softballs within minutes of the bite. This tool doesn't make those bumps go away, but it stops the itch IMMEDIATELY. I was a huge skeptic; how could a little suction cure this agonizingly itchy allergic reaction? I'll be honest. I still really don't know how it does, but it provides instant relief that no pill, cream, or injection ever has ever achieved for me. If you live anywhere where insect bites are common, you need to own one of these." —Customer
Get it from Amazon for $9.98.
www.amazon.com, www.amazon.com
Coop Sleep Goods is a small business specializing in pillows, pillowcases, and sleep products.
Promising review: "I hardly ever write reviews, but I have to for this. I saw this pillow on TikTok, and it got me curious, so I immediately came to Amazon. OMG, it’s such a game changer. I’m a side sleeper, and this pillow is heaven. It’s some of the most comfortable sleep I have had in ages. I love it so much, I bought a second one and have my eye on the body pillow. Obsessed! You need this in your bedroom." —MT
Get it from Amazon for $75.65+ (available in two sizes and two shapes).
BuzzFeed Shopping is service journalism first: our writers and editors spend all day shopping so you don’t have to, vetting products, fact-checking brand claims, and surfacing what actually helps in real life. We center readers over revenue, recommend products with authenticity (using real experiences, not ad-speak), and reflect our diverse audience, inclusive of a variety of price points, people, and needs. We cut through fake deals, favor useful info over glossy fluff, and recommend both budget and splurge options with context so you can decide what’s right for you — and still have a little fun along the way.
Reviews have been edited for length and/or clarity.
……Read full article on BuzzFeed-Shopping
Other
Comments
Leave a comment in Nestia App