Put down the coffee mug with their initial on it. Now! There are too many superior options for affordable under-$25 gifts for you to contribute to their (already too large) mug collection. A haunted dolls sticker book, Hokusai art Band-Aids and a first-aid kit bag, and a "field guide" to cryptids written like an actual field guide will feel super special to your recipient without blowing your holiday season budget. We've already done the (browser) window shopping for you.