The Princess of the 90s, Rachael Leigh Cook, was our It-Girl, starring in films like She’s All That, Josie & The Pussycats, and The Baby-Sitters Club. Today, she’s still an it-girl, turning heads in super-rare red carpet appearances that remind us she’s forever a fashion girlie we adore.

In case you missed it, the She’s All That star turned heads at the City Year Los Angeles’ 14th Annual Spring Break Gala held at SoFi Stadium earlier this month. And for the event, the gorgeous star put fans in a frenzy when she donned a cottagecore, AQUA Floral off-the-shoulder maxi dress.