While some had their eyes on Tom Cruise and Nicole Kidman’s 1990s romance, others were obsessed with the gothic It-couple: Johnny Depp and Winona Ryder.

From 1989 to 1993, they were the it-couple of the early 90s, constantly smooching and gushing about their romance. From the “Winona Forever” tattoo to their dramatic courtship gestures, everyone thought it was a fairytale.

After a quick engagement and starring in Edward Scissorhands, no one could see what happened: a breakup they’ve rarely spoken about decades after the fact.

However, when you look at their romance today, there are quite a few red flags fans have called out, like their age gap and how they got together being the biggest two.

Well, either way, let’s throw it back to the gothic couple of the decade and take a look at Ryder and Depp’s relationship, engagement, and breakup in photos.

See what we know about their romance below: