We know that freeing the nipple is having quite a moment, but that wasn’t the look Amanda Seyfried was going for at Sunday night’s Critics Choice Awards. Her exquisite Dior gown had other ideas as the dress almost had a complete meltdown on the red carpet and during the live show. 

The Dropout star shared the news that her stunning gold archival ensemble was “ripping and actually breaking” during an interview with Access Hollywood. Almost on cue, her sleeve fell off her shoulder as she quipped, “I’m just going to take off my dress. Honestly, it’s old, it’s beautiful!” What’s crazy about this story is that it’s not really an “old” dress, it’s from the designer’s “spring-summer 2020 collection,” per People, who noted that the “twisted, fringed gold lamé chiffon” fabric was very delicate.