Sleigh rides, caroling, a shimmying shirtless Martha Stewart — these are just some of the things that remind us all of Christmas, and remind Ana Gasteyer of decking her way into the holiday hall of fame at Saturday Night Live.

"I definitely feel very grateful, and it was sort of an accident, but I have had this recurring life at Christmastime," the actress tells EW of being forever tied to SNL Xmas thanks to the double-entendre-filled Schweddy Balls version of her and Molly Shannon's recurring "Delicious Dish"sketch. But it's her other famously festive featurette that stands out to Gasteyer as a career-solidifying achievement.