Someone needs to write whatever holiday rom-com Blake Lively and her husband, Ryan Reynolds, are apparently starring in this season. The couple have been spotted on a number of romantic walks in New York City over the past few weeks, most recently during a midday stroll downtown on Thursday.

In this rom-com universe, Reynolds has apparently assumed the role of the handsome but tastefully disheveled professor, opting for puffer vests and tailored jackets, while Lively plays perfectly into the small town fashionista in miniskirts, chunky boots, and high-waisted denim. Their latest scene had the two of them exchanging adoring looks under the glow of a Christmassy NYC; the paparazzi even caught ornaments and handmade snowflakes hanging in the windows behind them. (Swoon.)