In the original Archie Comics and '90s sitcom adaptation, teen witch Sabrina Spellman's endeavors have been relatively lighthearted, despite her connection to the supernatural. With Netflix's take on the concept, things have gotten much darker, which includes the entire supporting cast. Fans first met Gavin Leatherwood's Nicholas Scratch in the debut season, as he was one of the top students at the Academy of Unseen Arts. While their connection was initially adversarial, the pair's undeniable chemistry led towards a flirtatious relationship, ultimately solidifying their romantic intentions in the second season. The end of that season, however, saw Nicholas taken down to Hell, presenting some serious challenges for Part Three.