“Do we think Joe eats this much?” Penn Badgley currently has his head in Joe Goldberg’s fridge. Standing on the Los Angeles set of YOU‘s second season (out on Netflix today), Badgley is closely examining the collection of food that’s supposed to belong to his character. The shelves are filled with almond milk, hummus, yogurt, salsa, and more — and soon, Badgley will add a few bottles of celery juice to the mix. (Joe’s doing his best to adapt to the L.A. lifestyle.) But first, a couple of things might have to go. After Badgley poses the question, a crew member responds, “I have a lot in my fridge.” It takes Badgley no time at all to point out, “Yeah, but you’re not a murderer.”