The maker of Fireball Cinnamon Whisky has been sued for fraud for selling a beverage that, at a glance, looks like the spicy Fireball spirit famed for its ubiquity at college parties, but which doesn’t actually contain much of a key ingredient: whisky.

The malt beverage in dispute, called “Fireball Cinnamon,” has a lower alcohol content than its whisky-based cousin and can be sold at grocery stores and gas stations across the country. It comes in multiple sizes.