I know it’s not just me. We all have that one actor that we just know in our hearts would be perfect for that one role. And while we can only dream of making our own movies ourselves, it doesn’t stop us from insisting to anyone who listens that we would make fantastic casting directors.

Once in a while, I’ll stumble across a fan casting so perfect that I have to put my phone down and take a lap around my room. But sometimes, I’ll see a fan casting so criminal it makes me question my entire faith in the film industry. So, for our viewing pleasure, I’ve rounded up some of my faves, and some bonus ones that are just outrageous. Let’s dive in!

1. as Evelyn Hugo,

Ana De Armas