For someone who's created a career—an entire multimillion-dollar brand, really—out of refurbishing fixer-uppers, Jonathan Scott wasn't entirely prepared for his future to arrive in an already perfect package. 

And yet, somehow, 17 months into his romance with Zooey Deschanel, the HGTV personality is still marveling at all of the boxes she manages to tick. "She's a very considerate person, and that's what I'm looking for," he told People last January. "I had said before that the most important thing for me was a sense of humor. But you have to be kind, and she definitely is." Plus, as he told the mag, "She's smarter than me, she's funnier than me, and she's cuter than me!"