Unless otherwise specified, all sizes in this post are listed in women's.

1. A pair of dressy flat sandals to give yourself the gift of never having to think about which sandal you're going to wear again, because these will go with ~everything~.

amazon.com

Promising review: "These sandals are super comfy and very cute. They look more expensive than they are. They are true to size. They are very comfortable, and the color goes with everything." —lvigod

Get them from Amazon for $28.89+ (available in sizes 5.5–11 and six colors)

2. A highly reviewed pair of memory foam cork sandals so you can get that Super Popular Nature-Sandal look, for less than half the price! Which also means you can pick, like, FOUR DIFFERENT COLORS for the price of one pair from "that brand." You're welcome.

amazon.com, amazon.com

Promising review: "These sandals felt comfortable right off the start. I have trouble keeping flip-flops on, but the strap and toe strap keep it exactly on your foot. The cushion and arch are very good. You feel like you're walking barefoot. I will definitely recommend!" —Gardengal

Get them from Amazon for $40.99+ (available in sizes 6–11 and 12 styles/colors).

3. Or a Cushionaire cork footbed sandal for a less strappy (but equally comfy and affordable!) look.

amazon.com

Promising review: "These Cushionaire sandals are amazing! I got the brown pair, and the color is exactly what I was hoping for! A cool-toned brown that goes with everything. They look just like Birkenstock but for a fraction of the price! I sized up to a 9.5 (I’m normally a 9) because the reviews were mixed, and I’m so glad I did. The fit is perfect. The heel cushion makes them incredibly comfortable I can already tell I’ll be living in these all summer long. Don’t hesitate on these, seriously!" —Daniela K.

Get them from Amazon for $27.99+ (available in sizes 5–12, in wide sizes, and 21 colors).

4. A cushy pair of slides that will basically live by your door at all times because they're the PERFECT slip-on-and-go situation. Plus, they come in plenty of colors, so you can find the perfect look to complement your chosen summer vibes.

amazon.com, amazon.com

Promising review: "I have these slides in 7 colors. They are beyond comfortable! They actually feel therapeutic when I put them on. Whenever I wear the cow or leopard prints, no fail, I get complimented on them! I had a woman chasing through a parking lot last week to ask where I got them! I wear them all the time, and they are extremely well-made. Highly recommend!" —K Lamel

Get them from Amazon for $20.38+ (available in women's sizes 4–16 and 15 colors).

5. Some glitzy Sam Edelman sandals perfect for summer brunch plans, baby showers, and everything else that could use a touch of glam without breaking your feet.

DSW

Promising review: "I love these! True to size, comfy, and stylish! You can wear these with leggings and a blazer or with a maxi, or even at the beach (but be careful not to ruin them, cause they’re pretty haha)." —Yellow1

Get them from DSW for $68.98 (originally $110; available in sizes 6–10).

6. A pair of fully adjustable Teva Hurricane sandals because there's no reason to put up with awkward toe-rubbing and too-tight strap pain when Tevas exist. And they have a cute retro look that is sure to have you reaching for them all summer long.

amazon.com, amazon.com

Promising review: "Very comfortable and fashionable shoes. I have been wearing them now for two weeks, and I've worn them everywhere. To the park, the beach, and around. I am 7 months pregnant now, so I appreciate how easy they are to put on and adjust. They are also supportive, not like a flip-flop. They are also very easy to clean. I got wet sand and dry sand on them, and it came off like nothing. I just had to brush the dry sand and lightly rinse the wet sand. It didn't stay stuck in the crevices underneath. They also dried fast and still look good. They don't look all weathered. I 100% recommend these sandals if you want something more like a shoe than a flip-flop and just a great summer shoe overall." —Ariel Szczupakiewicz

Get them from Amazon for $79.95 (available in sizes 5–14 and 49 styles/colors)

7. A pair of Merrells for any puddle-jumping, damp gardening, and wet sidewalk stomping you've got ahead of you this year. These are designed to dry quickly and handle all kinds of terrain, so no fears about these getting ruined the first, second, or 100th time you put them on your feet!

amazon.com

Promising reviews: "I had these sandals years ago (more than 10) wore them out. Couldn’t find them in stores, so I was so happy they popped up on Amazon to buy them. Yep still my favorite sandals with arch support, and so comfortable. They stay on your foot like you have shoes on, unlike flip-flops that snap as you walk." —Jo M.

"I've been ordering Merrell sandals for years and I learned to order a whole size more for the summer, since my feet swell in the summer months. I don't like flip-flops since they have no support. Merrell sandals are extremely comfortable, they are easy to clean, look good, and the variety of colors is excellent. The sole is very well-made and they last for years. The ones that have the space for the big toe are very attractive and feel good on your feet. I have over 6 pairs of them." —Ski-dogs

Get them from Amazon for $59.99+ (available in sizes 6–11 and 16 colors). 

8. And some Keen closed-toe sporty sandals if you want those same puddle-jumping abilities, but with a lil' extra toe protection.

amazon.com

Promising review: "I got these shoes for camping because flip-flops just don't work out in the forest. Everybody else had shoes like these so I figured I needed a pair too. I got them and wore them around for short periods of time and found them to be very comfortable. Just came back from a 5-day camping trip in the forest, wore them every day and they were very comfortable. We had rain, we had hai,l and we had sunny weather and they work great for everything." —stephanie

Get them from Amazon for $64.95+ (available in sizes 4.5–12 and 28 colors/patterns). 

9. A pair of Brynn sandals because everyone needs the perfect go-to sandal and congrats! You just found yours! A comfy padded footbed, a lightweight EVA outsole, and adjustable Velcro straps, these sporty shoes are designed to feel like you've got (very fashion-forward) clouds on your feet.

Coach

Promising reviews: "I got these and I’ve had them now for two years. I am currently pregnant and I am wearing them daily now. I will be ordering another pair in case they stop making them. These are my go-to daily wear shoes. They’ve gotten wet a few times and they still look amazing. I got mine all black." —RinaMena

"These sandals are so adorable and run true to size. A must-have for the summer." —Taffy N.

Get them from Coach for $195+ (available in sizes 5–11 and seven colors).

10. A pair of platform Crocs sandals everyone is going to ask about, because not only are they heckin' stylish, but they're also SUPREMELY comfy. Yes, you're going to have to say, "They are really Crocs," 700 times. Yes, it's still worth it.

amazon.com

Promising review: "Having various foot issues, I can't do flip-flops, or go barefoot, or wear totally flat sandals. These Croc Brooklyn sandals are heavenly! They cushion your feet, and the bands and wedge-style sole provide support and all-day comfort. I have two pairs (black and tan) and live in them all spring and summer. They go with everything from jeans and shorts to dresses and Capri pants. My #1 go-to sandal!" —Cheryl meister

Get them from Amazon for $50+ (available in sizes 4–11 and four colors). 

11. A pair of sports sandals reviewers say you can wear from dawn until dusk and still want to go back and wear the very next day. That's the kind of comfort we DESERVE in 2025.

amazon.com

Promising review: "A friend of mine recommended Ecco sandals to me when I was admiring the pair she was wearing. I told her I needed a good sandal that had arch support, as at my age, I can’t wear simple flat leather sandals or flip-flops anymore. She said Ecco is all she’ll buy — that they are super adjustable and comfortable — and while they are a bit pricey, they last for many years. I figured that makes the pricing a lot more reasonable if I could get at least a couple of years out of a pair. Got my first pair yesterday, and they literally are the best-made sandals I’ve ever owned! So comfortable!! I can see them lasting many years, which ends up making them priced quite well. I will be buying more colors! These sandals are amazing!! I can’t recommend them enough!!" —TWH4Gail

Get them from Amazon for $93.41++ (available in sizes 4–12.5 and 35 colors).

12. A pair of Dr. Martens fisherman sandals if the fishwife trend is reeling you in (get it?) and you want to add your own punk vibes to the mix.

Ashley Schumacher/BuzzFeed, Dr. Martens

Promising review: "I love these shoes, they are so cute! I only had the shoes for 3 days and then wore them for 15 hours working at a college orientation, and they were comfortable all day. I was amazed! Easy to style, sizing is true, and the look is exactly what I was looking for." —Summer S

Get them from Dr. Martens for $150 (available in sizes 5–12 and three colors).

13. Or a similar pair from Anthropologie but without the big sole if you want a more trim fisherman vibe.

Anthropologie

Promising review: "These sandals are fantastic and a staple for summer. They run TTS and are incredibly comfortable with no time to break in. The leather is butter-soft, and I receive compliments on them every time I wear them. I will be getting more colors!" —Nicole

Get them from Anthropologie for $125 (available in sizes 36–41 and four colors).

14. A pair of buckle slides as spunky as they are functional. A deep heel cup, arch support, and adjustable straps mean these will feel custom made to your foot.

amazon.com

Promising review: "These shoes are one of the most comfortable slip-ons. They are much safer than flip-flops and have good arch support, and you can adjust the width. I love them." —Obscure

Get them from Amazon for $26.99+ (available in sizes 5–11 and 19 colors). 

15. A pair of geometric cutout slip-ons to up the quirk without upping the discomfort. Your feet are in good hands thanks to the exclusively patented footbed designed for long-term wear.

Nordstrom

Promising reviews: "Very comfortable shoes. This brand is very well-made." —SLC in Az

"They are extremely comfortable and fashionable. The red color is outstanding with black pants. I’ve received many compliments on them." —Emc4

Get them from Nordstrom for $140 (available in sizes 5–11.5 and six colors).

16. A pair of bejeweled sandals because when you walk in the room, you can still make the whole place ✨shimmer. ✨

amazon.com, amazon.com

Promising review: "These adorable sandals are nice with my jeans, leggings, and summer dresses. I much prefer them to flip-flops — not only for the pretty style, but for the strap that keeps them from slapping against my heel when I walk. I wore them to church last Sunday and to a birthday party yesterday and got a lot of compliments on them. They’ve got lots of bling, but not over-the-top. Very pretty and feminine." —WynterFire11

Get them from Amazon for $31.99+ (available in sizes 6–10 and seven colors).

17. A pair of low wedges with a crossover strap if you want some unique tan lines when you're catching rays.

amazon.com

Promising review: "I have a really hard time with heels but these were comfortable and not difficult to walk in, even in grass. They stretched, but didn't 'snap' on the heel (like a flip-flop) as some other similar styles I tried did. Thinking I might need to buy some more colors." —Shannon

Get them from Amazon for $39.98+ (available in sizes 5–11, including wide sizes, and three colors). 

18. Some Quince platform sandals for a little more structure and a lot more WOW factor. Plus, they're very comfortable, according to reviewers.

Quince

Promising review: "I purchased these heels for graduation in NYC. I received so many compliments on them and walked all over NYC without blisters...they are not only beautiful, but super comfortable! Great quality." —KRIS

Get them from Quince for $89.90 (available in sizes 5–12)

19. A pair of Crocs slides to get an excellent shoe and an excellent canvas for all of your Crocs shoe charms.

amazon.com

Promising review: "I needed a new pair of rubber sandals. I love these as they are dressier than flip-flops, and I can put Crocs charms on them. They are raised yet stable. Highly recommend." —CJ

Get them from Amazon for $19.99+ (available in sizes 4–11 and 14 colors).

20. A rhinestone-embellished open-toe slingback sandal that has just a ~glimmer~ of stylistic oomph so it's both the perfect everyday shoe and great for those in-between — but frequent — casual-but-elevated kinda meetups that seem to pop up every summer. (Looking at you, new fancy brunch place!)

amazon.com, amazon.com

Promising review: "I was shocked when I went to buy a new pair in a different color and it said I've had these sandals for three years!! They're still very comfortable and in good shape!" —Holly N.

Get them from Amazon for $33.11+ (available in 5–12 and 16 colors).

21. A pair of faux-wood Dr. Scholl's slides if you remember the OG Dr. Scholl's version and want the new, improved updated silhouette in your closet.

amazon.com

Promising reviews: "I love how comfortable they are, they feel nicer than my favorite flip-flops!!  —Tanna LoHouse

"Fun and nostalgic, and actually more comfortable than the original wooden ones. I like that these have the brass studs to attach the upper to the clog, and there is hidden velcro to make adjusting these a cinch! Can't wait to wear these out!" —Amazon Customer

Get them from Amazon for $44.99 (available in sizes 6–11 and three colors). 

22. A pair of Keen back strap sandals for making sure your sandals stay on their feet as they should in the most colorful, comfiest way possible.

amazon.com

Promising review: "Obsessed! Hands-down, the most comfortable pair of sandals I have ever owned. My feet hurt when wearing flip-flops. These have good arch support and are comfortable for walking and long wear. Ordering another color!" —Tia Buchs

Get them from Amazon for $71.73+ (available in sizes 5–11, including wide sizes, and 17 colors). 

23. A pair of slip-ons perfect for traveling, whether that be via plane, train, or automobile or for just traversing to your fave grocery store to see the summer produce options. The built-in memory foam footbed will help every step feel like walking on a cloud, no matter where those steps take you.

amazon.com, amazon.com

Promising review: "These sandals are so comfy! I've had mine for a couple of years and they are still as comfortable today as they were when I first got them. I was a loyal buyer of another popular brand that look similar to these, but these are just as comfortable and hold up just as well. I will purchase more in other colors!" —Dog mom

Get them from Amazon for $37.99 (available in sizes 6–11 and three styles/colors).

24. A pair of minimalistic sandals to give you the perfect shoe pairing to go with all your tunics and peasant tops.

amazon.com

Promising review: "I don't usually spend $120 on shoes, but I was smitten by these beauties and decided to splurge. I'm a solid 8 M, and these fit my feet perfectly. I like these sandals because they're more 'solid' than a lot of the flip-flop types. I don't want to worry about my shoes coming off. These cover a lot of your foot, affording you some protection. The leather is buttery. But they don't look clunky or like old lady sandals. If I could find these on sale, I'd buy some more in different colors. Maybe at the end of the season?" —Amazon Customer

Get them from Amazon for $109.95 (available in sizes 6–11 and seven colors). 

25. A pair of cute colorful wedge sandals so perfectly meant for warm weather, you'll wonder how you ever survived a spring and summer without these.

amazon.com

Promising review: "I don’t wear high heels anymore, but this espadrille with the flat raised bottom gives the same look. As comfortable as my flip-flops, but great for summer parties and other occasions where you want to look more dressed up. Love them!!" —Vicki

Get them from Amazon for $47.85 (available in sizes 5–11, including wide widths, and five colors). 

26. A pair of Naturalizer heeled sandals with a cushy footbed designed to be lightweight and comfy while still making you feel elegant and ~above~ outfit panics.

amazon.com, amazon.com

Promising review: "I hate any and all heels. They are usually painful and I don’t last more than 30 minutes in them. I wore these shoes for 10 hours and even danced in them at the end of the night. What is this sorcery? These were more comfortable than my flip-flops. You could probably run at least a 10K in these if you had to." —Jennifer B

Get them from Amazon for $53.50+ (available in sizes 5–12, including wide widths, and 35 colors).

27. A pair of ultra-stylish Serene sandals to elevate your summer fits without sacrificing comfort. These have three adjustable straps (bye-bye blisters!) and are designed to survive heavy rain and dunks in water.

Portland Gear

Portland Gear is all about making water-resistant bags and accessories, so if you're like me and somehow ALWAYS get your shoes wet (and sometimes even your bags), their products are designed to air dry naturally so you can keep on with your day no matter how drenched you get!

Y'all, I keep reaching for these over my beloved Birks. They're THAT comfortable.

Get them from Portland Gear for $129 (available in women's sizes 6.5–15.5, men's sizes 5–14, and three colors).

Reviews have been edited for length and/or clarity.