While celebrity weddingsoften get covered by the media, with perhaps even full spreads in Vogue, celebrity proposals are mostly kept private. So, of course, we always love to hear stories of celebrities getting down on one knee and saying “Yes!”

Most recently, Yellowjackets starMelanie Lynskeyopened up about how her husband Jason Ritter popped the question back in 2016. “My husband’s first proposal was so confusing I didn’t know what was happening,” Lynskey said in a recent appearance at The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon. “The day before I had been looking at rings and I tried one on and I was like ‘Oh, kind of looks like an engagement ring almost, I don’t think I’m going to get it.'”