Sean Murray may be a constant presence on the nation's televisions thanks to his starring role on CBS's NCIS, but 10 years before he made his 2003 debut as NCIS Special Agent Timothy McGee, he was stealing preteen hearts in a little movie called Hocus Pocus.

EW caught up with Murray to mark NCIS's 450th episode and asked him to dish about his status as a ghost hottie and his thoughts on the 2022 sequel, which saw the return of Bette Midler, Sarah Jessica Parker, and Kathy Najimy's centuries-old witches to plague Salem, Mass.