Our eyes can reveal a lot about us, including how well we care for our skin. While pricey treatments may seem more effective, many of the best drugstore eye creams work just as well—if not better—to smooth fine lines, reduce puffiness, and minimize dark circles. Much like the rest of your skincare go-tos, hardworking ingredients are typically what distinguish more expensive eye creams from the ones found at your local drugstore. However, many options contain similar ingredients, like caffeine and retinol, to combat dark circles and smooth fine lines.