Warning: Below contains spoilers for the Oct. 25 episode of The Masked Singer.

Yer a wizard, Jenny McCarthy.

After all, makeup magic allowed the Masked Singer judge to transform into Albus Dumbledore for the Fox singing competition's Harry Potter week episode on Oct. 25. Donning a prosthetic nose, aging makeup, a gray wig, a large beard and bushy eyebrows, McCarthy looked unrecognizable—and at least 50 years older than her actual self—as the famous Hogwarts headmaster.