The Traitors came out swinging with its second season on Peacock, filling the cast of its sophomore installment with popular reality TV veterans, rather than mixing in regular folks (as it did in Season 1). Along with big names like Survivor's Parvati Shallow and Big Brother's Dan Gheesling, the most successful and popular player in the history of MTV's The Challenge was a focal point of the Season 2 advertising campaign. Fresh off the first season of House of Villains, Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio seemed poised to be a featured character in The Traitors Season 2, but he was shockingly murdered by the Traitors on the very first night of the competition.