After winning the WWE NXT Women's Championship at Stand & Deliver during WrestleMania weekend, Indi Hartwell was already set to get her first Title defense opportunity during tonight's NXT. After Zoey Stark interrupted her celebration, the match was made official, and Stark looked to make Hartwell's reign the shortest in NXT history. Hartwell wouldn't go down though, no matter how many times Stark knocked her down, and ultimately it was a reversal by Hartwell on a pin that got her the 3-count and the win. Tiffany Stratton then made it known she was up next, but that's when Cora Jade made her surprise return to NXT and attacked Hartwell, staking her claim on the Title before a staredown with Stratton.