Will Ferrell is joining Saturday Night Live’s Five-Timers Club (the rare designation for the holy ones who’ve hosted SNL five times) this weekend. So, naturally, he made the mandatory stop at the nearby 30 Rock stage of The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon to shoot the shit and laugh a whole bunch with his former SNL castmate.

After they talked about Thanksgiving plans, Boston, and Dunkin’ Donuts, the chat turned to famous SNL sketches. The first one to come up? You guessed it: “More Cowbell,” in which Blue Oyster Cult is recording "Don't Fear the Reaper" with Will Ferrell on the titular instrument and Walken as the band's producer.