A 20-year-old woman from Minnesota in the US was found dead in a cornfield, naked with her throat slashed and multiple stab wounds, less than a quarter of a mile from the party she had left for a late-night walk.

In the summer of 1985, Kristin O'Connell ignored her mother's advice and travelled to Ovid, New York, to visit James Vermeersch, a man she had met on holiday in Florida earlier that year and had been writing to ever since. However, the trip took an unpleasant turn when Kristin discovered that James had a secret girlfriend in New York.

Article continues below ADVERTISEMENT

Kristin was excited about her trip to the Finger Lakes region, planning her journey for August 12. Her mother Phyllis told NBC's Dateline that despite their concerns, she and Kristin's father decided their daughter was an adult and deserved independence, according to the Morbid Podcast.

Kristin's father Michael discovered James had another girlfriend that August and planned to tell Kristin when she arrived - likely causing Kristin to cut her visit short.

"She was so bright with excitement," said Phyllis. Unexpectedly, just a day into the trip, Phyllis received a worrying call from a payphone in Ovid, with Kristin saying she would end her trip early and return home the next day, reports <a href="https://www.themirror.com/news/us-news/minnesota-woman-20-found-naked-1158651" rel="Follow" target="_self">the Mirror US</a>.

"Something wasn't right in her voice," Phyllis told Dateline.

The horrific saga took a grim turn mere hours later when Kristin was discovered brutally murdered, and even after four decades, the authorities seem no closer to cracking the case of her killer. Kristin, who was nearing the end of her studies in hotel-motel management, had only a few weeks until her junior year began in September 1985.

Kristin, at a trailer on James' family land with his mates, decided to take a twilight stroll—a common habit back at her place—right after James mentioned he'd pop out for pizza. Unfortunately, upon his return with no sign of Kristin, a search was promptly initiated by the partygoers, all to no avail.

The plot thickened on the afternoon of August 15, 1985, when James alerted the Ovid police to Kristin's disappearance, noting she was last sighted around 11pm to 11:30pm, venturing out barefoot without her handbag. Despite the fruitless search at 1:30 am by the revellers, Kristin stayed missing.

James' friend, David Chamberlain, 17, corroborated Jim's account and dismissed any notion of discord at the do. "She just went for a walk and didn't come back," he insisted.

An exhaustive search involving nearly 80 firefighters and police assembled in a bid to locate Kristin, alas, achieved nothing. The dreadful truth emerged on August 16, 1985, when the searchers happened upon a ghastly sight.

Kristin's body was found in a cornfield, half a mile from where she was last seen, after being savagely stabbed and her throat cut. Neighbours reported a "horrifying" scream at the time of the murder.

Although there was no sign of sexual assault, police suspected she may have been attacked while resisting such an attempt. The New York State Police launched an inquiry into potential suspects who could have targeted the young woman.

The road by the cornfield, often used by Seneca Army Depot employees and campers heading to the Golden Buck, a nearby bar, became a focal point of the investigation.

Witness accounts placed Kristin on County Road 139 around the time James claimed, while Phyllis suggested discomfort with drug use at the party might have prompted her to leave.

As summer wore on, investigators encountered alarming leads, including a sighting of a blue or green car pulling up beside Kristin, with another vehicle close by.

State Police Sgt Thomas Warren made a public appeal for more details to locate these cars, hoping other witnesses might have seen something similar.

Hints emerged that two men might have been shadowing Kristin on the fateful night. A pillowcase marked with the name of a local mental health facility was discovered near the road, adding another twist to the mystery.

Yet, the most peculiar incident was an anonymous phone call received by investigators days after the murder. The frantic caller directed police to search the boot of a green Chevy on Main Street in Waterloo for vital information leading to Kristin's killer.

"I'm getting out of town because I told him not to do it. I told him not to do it. I'm heading out of town," the caller said before abruptly ending the call.

There is no record of such a vehicle. Despite police suggesting the murder was a crime of opportunity, rumours persist in Ovid and beyond that certain individuals possess knowledge of Kristin's fate in 1985 but remain silent.

At the time police said: "Everybody at this party came from well to families in the community they are respected in this area."

Another odd point raised on the same social media page is that local resident Donald 'Nutsy' Chamberlain owned the trailer where Kristin stayed less than 24 hours before her murder. He also owns the Golden Buck restaurant mentioned earlier and has a sign on the premises stating that "anyone who talks about the O'Connell murder will be asked to leave".

In 1995, the Democrat and Chronicle reported that then-District Attorney Donna Cathy pointed the finger at Gary Harris, as hairs from an African American were discovered at the murder scene, with Harris reportedly being the only black male in Ovid at the time.

Acting Seneca County Judge W Patrick Falvey called for a DNA analysis of hair and blood evidence from 1985 to crack the case, but was stymied by the lack of probable cause connecting Harris to the crime.

Harris's defence lawyer argued emphatically: "Being in the community or being black in the community does not meet the requisite proof."

Despite this, officials maintain that Harris is merely "one of many" subjects under scrutiny in the ongoing investigation. Scrutinising the forensics in this enigma-filled murder case, one notices odd details.

Kristin's bloodstained clothes were found carefully placed next to her body in a cornfield; however, a heavy rain on the night of her death has likely washed away some evidence.

Regardless, the case still boasts an overwhelming cache of physical clues – a total of 318 items linked to the horrific crime – including Kristin's fingernails, a blood-drenched sweater, a pillowcase, and potentially hundreds of strands of hair. Despite the plethora of material and advancements in forensic science, no new tests are currently being pursued.

In a bitter blow for the family of Kristin, a top Dutch lab's 2009 offer to analyse case evidence was blocked by New York State Health Department on grounds of lacking local certification.

Outraged by the red tape, District Attorney Richard Swineheart told the Ithaca Journal: "We feel this is our last, best effort to solve this case. We are very frustrated with the bureaucracy of the Department of Health."

Kirsten's mother Phyllis and a Minnesota senator hit a brick wall in their bid to persuade authorities to allow the Amsterdam laboratory to seek New York certification.

The O'Connell family has not given up and has taken their fight to Change.org, starting a petition demanding DNA analysis to further the investigation. Yet another setback emerged in 2010, as they were told by the New York Inspector General that a forensic specialist might have tampered with Kristin's case by "dry-labbing" – faking test results.

SUBSCRIBE Invalid email

We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our Privacy Policy

Phyllis expressed her despair about Gerry Veeder, who was linked to the scandal and handled the original evidence: "In 1985 he did the initial evidence. I don't know how many items but anything to do with cloth because that's what he handled. I mean, my God - this is an important job they're doing there and how could they allow this and not be supervised properly?".

In a turn of events as shocking as it is frustrating, it has come to light that a skilled team of cold case specialists, spearheaded by a former head honcho at the FBI's Violent Criminal Apprehension Program, offered their expert forensics services gratis - courtesy of a recognised New York State forensics laboratory - to sift through all the physical evidence in Kristin's unsolved murder case.

This magnanimous gesture was intended to be a cornerstone of an in-the-works documentary delving into the homicide, directed by none other than two-time Academy Award winner Bill Guttentag; an innovative move aimed squarely at avoiding the bureaucratic obstacles encountered over ten years prior with a Dutch lab's involvement.

However, the New York State Police passed up the chance, curtailing any backing for the campaign. Spokesperson Mark O'Donnell from the State Police justifiably cited policy restrictions against folding in external entities into live murder probes.

The official stance from State Police was unwavering: "As in all cases, the State Police does not share critical information, evidence or the techniques used in solving cases. By sharing such information, it could jeopardize the integrity of the investigation."

Despite the seemingly ample scratch of proof swirling around Kristin's tragic murder mystery, no answers have been forthcoming. A $10,000 bounty was dangled in 2010 for clues leading to her murderer's conviction, followed by a declaration in 2015 from the police detailing over 1,900 exhausted leads, all to no avail.

Phyllis is relentlessly pushing for the police to either re-examine the evidence with contemporary forensic methods or close the case, which would enable her to file a Freedom of Information request to access the evidence.

Additionally, Phyllis is campaigning for a legal amendment that would mandate all police forces to establish dedicated cold case squads, ensuring cases like Kristin's don't just get shuffled between detectives over time.

She stated: "I think there are people up there who know what happened but are afraid to come forward. I believe people are scared. I know I can't bring her back. But I can't rest until I find out who did this to her."

The Mirror has reached out to Seneca County Police for a statement. The authorities continue their appeal for information on Kristin O'Connell's murder and encourage anyone with insights to contact the New York State Police Major Crimes Unit at (585) 398–4100.