Ryan Murphy’s first look at the cast for American Horror Story: 1984 might have shown some fans a bit more than they expected to see.

The spooky anthology’s creator uploaded video teasers for the new season to Instagram Thursday, and viewers zeroed in on a clip of newly mustachioed Glee star Matthew Morrison walking into a summer camp bunk in tight gym shorts. He walks toward the camera, showing off his outfit and his… manhood, which the camera then emphasizes from other angles.