Cassidy Gifford‘s proposal is one she’s sure to never forget!

Days after Kathie Lee Gifford announced that her daughter had gotten engaged to boyfriend Ben Wierda, Cassidy, 26, shared some hilarious details about the milestone moment.

In an Instagram Story on Tuesday, Cassidy revealed that her husband-to-be popped the question while she was chowing down on a quesadilla. As a fun engagement gift, her brother’s fiancée Erika Brown sent her a blanket that resembled a tortilla.