Is James Charles secretly a long lost Kardashian-Jenner sibling?

Last week YouTube beauty star, 20, recreated Kylie Jenner‘s recent sexy Instagram snap by copying her outfit, pose and even hair flip in a new photo — and the resemblance is truly uncanny.

On Friday, Jenner shared two Instagram pics standing in front of a beige Jeep wearing a printed skintight jumpsuit with a gray croc-embossed baguette bag while giving a smoldering glance back at the camera.