The new Paramount+ drama 1883 may feature married couple Tim McGrawand Faith Hill in their first-ever joint project as James and Margaret Dutton, but the real breakout from the Yellowstone prequel is Isabel May – the 21 –year-old actress who plays the couple's headstrong daughter Elsa. Since May doesn't have quite the same resume as her on-screen parents, EW asked the ingénue to explain how she ended up on a horse in Taylor Sheridan's western joint.